ArchiveCase 51 of 200 · Category 03
Category 03The Wellness Hijack

Keto / paleo brands

"Grass-Fed Ghee"

STOLEN
The Appropriation

Keto / paleo brands

Item
"Grass-Fed Ghee"
Retail
₹2,075$25
Spin
"Keto superfood"
Repackaged as Western wellness trend

Various keto and paleo brands market "Grass-Fed Ghee" as a newly discovered "superfood" fat, often priced significantly higher than its traditional value. This marketing approach frequently overlooks its deep cultural and spiritual roots in India, presenting it as a novel health product. The narrative of discovery by Western wellness trends often overshadows the centuries of traditional use and knowledge associated with this ancient staple.

The Origin

घी

Ghee

True Value
₹500$6.02
Category
03 · The Wellness Hijack
Sacred clarified butter from Vedic India

Ghee, or clarified butter, holds profound significance in Hindu traditions, originating in Vedic India. It is an essential element in religious rituals, symbolizing purity and nourishment, and is offered to deities in ceremonies. Beyond its sacred role, ghee is a staple in Indian culinary practices, valued for its rich flavor and medicinal properties in Ayurveda, and is traditionally prepared in homes and by local dairies across the subcontinent.

FX reference: 1 USD ≈ ₹83 — for comparison only

The Story

The Backstory

Keto and paleo brands began marketing "Grass-Fed Ghee" as a "keto superfood" for around $25. This product, presented as a new discovery, was positioned for health-conscious consumers in Western markets, often without acknowledging its rich cultural heritage. The marketing emphasized its fat content and suitability for specific dietary trends.

The Cultural Origin

Ghee (घी) is a clarified butter product originating from Vedic India, where it holds profound sacred significance in Hindu rituals and is a cornerstone of Indian cooking. Traditionally prepared through a meticulous process of simmering butter to separate milk solids, it is revered not only for its rich flavor and nutritional value but also for its symbolic purity. It is an essential offering in pujas and a staple in Ayurvedic medicine, embodying centuries of cultural and spiritual practice.

The News Story

The appropriation of ghee was called out by various cultural commentators and members of the Indian diaspora, who objected to its rebranding as a "keto superfood" and a "discovered" fat. Critics highlighted the erasure of its deep-rooted cultural and sacred origins, pointing out that the product was being sold at a significantly inflated price ($25 compared to a fair value of around ₹500) while its traditional context was ignored. The public response centered on the lack of credit and the commodification of a sacred item.

Editor's Notes

Sacred in Hindu ritual and central to Indian cooking. Sold as a 'discovered' fat.

Further Reading

Reporting forthcoming

Pass the receipt on