ArchiveCase 134 of 200 · Category 10
Category 10Culinary Rebranding II

Vegan meat conglomerates

"Pulled Pork Substitute"

STOLEN
The Appropriation

Vegan meat conglomerates

Item
"Pulled Pork Substitute"
Retail
$$
Spin
"Modern meat-free breakthrough"
Repackaged as Western vegan innovation

Vegan meat conglomerates have marketed 'pulled pork substitute' products, often using jackfruit, as a modern meat-free breakthrough. These companies have patented specific preservation methods for jackfruit, presenting them as novel Western innovations. This approach overlooks and effectively erases the centuries of Indian culinary knowledge and traditional uses of Kathal as a meat alternative.

The Origin

कटहल

Kathal (Jackfruit)

Region
Pan-India
True Value
₹40/kg$0.48/kg
Category
10 · Culinary Rebranding II
Pan-Indian Kathal culinary tradition

Kathal (कटहल), or jackfruit, has been a staple across India for centuries, celebrated for its versatility and nutritional value. From curries in the south to koftas in the north, this fruit is integral to diverse regional cuisines. Its fibrous texture, especially when unripe, has long been utilized as a meat substitute, providing sustenance and flavor in vegetarian diets.

FX reference: 1 USD ≈ ₹83 — for comparison only

The Story

The Backstory

Vegan meat conglomerates launched a "pulled pork substitute" at a mid-range price point, marketing it as a modern, meat-free breakthrough. This product, made from jackfruit, was presented as an innovative Western culinary development, despite its long history in other cultures.

The Cultural Origin

Kathal, or jackfruit (Artocarpus heterophyllus), is a large, versatile fruit indigenous to India and Southeast Asia. For centuries, it has been a staple in Indian cuisine, particularly when unripe, where its fibrous texture is masterfully prepared to mimic meat in curries, stir-fries, and stews. Across various regions of India, communities have developed intricate preservation methods and diverse culinary applications for kathal, reflecting its deep cultural and nutritional significance.

The News Story

The marketing of jackfruit as a novel Western vegan innovation sparked criticism from food writers and cultural commentators. Objections centered on the conglomerates' appropriation of a traditional Indian foodstuff, specifically highlighting how patented preservation methods for jackfruit were presented as new breakthroughs, completely disregarding centuries of Indian Kathal cuisine and its indigenous knowledge systems.

Editor's Notes

Specific preservation methods for jackfruit patented and marketed as a Western vegan breakthrough, ignoring centuries of Indian Kathal cuisine.

Further Reading

Reporting forthcoming

Pass the receipt on